HLS Profs Sign Letter Slamming 'Victim-Centered' Sexual Harassment Policies
Law professors Janet E. Halley and Elizabeth Bartholet ’62 signed the letter three weeks ago, along with academics hailing from institutions including Northwestern University and the University of Pennsylvania Law School.
“‘Victim-centered’ practices… threaten to subvert the objective collection and presentation of evidence in administrative, civil, and criminal sexual assault proceedings,” the letter reads.
The letter states these victim-centered practices are based in the “believe the victim” ideology they say sprang up in the 1990s. The document’s authors assert that supporters of this ideology called for “swift and unquestioning judgments about the facts of [sexual] harassment without standard evidentiary procedures.”
The letter culminates in a “call to restore due process and fundamental fairness” in university sexual harassment cases by ending the “use of victim-centered, trauma-informed, and believe the victim practices.”
At Harvard, Halley has been one of the most outspoken critics of policies and procedures pertaining to sexual assault cases. When the University adopted new sexual harassment policies in the fall of 2014, Halley numbered among the 28 signatories of an open letter that criticized these changes.
Halley and Bartholet also comprised two of the four Harvard Law School faculty members who submitted a memo to the U.S. Department of Justice last year asking for a review of the standards outlined in the 2011 “Dear Colleague” letter. That letter was an Obama-era order directed colleges and universities receiving federal funding to “use a lower standard of proof” in sexual assault cases as well as establishing a broader definition of the term sexual harassment. U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos rescinded those guidelines in September.
Halley said in an interview Tuesday she signed the recent open letter because it aligned with her belief that the policies and procedures on sexual assault need to be revised.
“I signed it because I thought it was correct. I’ve seen the bad effects of politically slanted training,” Halley said.
—Staff writer Aidan F. Ryan can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow him on Twitter @AidanRyanNH.
Read more in NewsLongwood Students Protest Gun Violence
Law School Faculty and Staff Commend Student Activism
‘Troubling’ Climate of Sexual Assault: One Year Later
Title IX Officer Mia Karvonides to Leave Harvard
DeVos Title IX Review Sparks Concern From Activists
If Betsy DeVos Won’t Do It, Harvard MustHarvard must combat the narrative of DeVos’s decision—automatically doubting survivors’ allegations of sexual assault—and, instead, fully attend to students involved in sexual harassment cases.